Easy Chicken Pie - Homemade Chicken Pie Recipe (2024)

FULL of Chicken and the best light gravy you EVER tasted! This easy Chicken Pie will have your family BEGGING for more so you better make two! Easy Chicken Pie – Homemade Chicken Pie Recipe!

Why This Recipe Works

• Easy
• Fast
• Uses ingredients you probably already have at home.
• Makes its own gravy!
• Make several in the same time it takes to make one
• Freezes GREAT!

Here’s How It’s Done

STEP 1. Cook up your chicken (pan fry or boil, your choice) (or use rotisserie chicken!)

STEP 2. Mix with the other ingredients and pour into a pie shell!

STEP 3. Put the top crust on the pie, cut slits and bake!

STEP 4. DIG IN!

Frequently Asked Questions about Chicken Pie

How Do I Thicken My Chicken Pie Filling?

This pie thickens its own filling while baking. That is what the two Tbs of flour are for. That said, you will notice that it is still a little runny if you cut it right away after baking. It’s best to let it cool completely to allow the inside of the pie to congeal.

Can You Cook Chicken Pie From Frozen?

You sure can! Set the oven on 325 and bake for about an hour to an hour and 20 minutes. If it appears that the crust is becoming too dark, cover with aluminum foil.

How Do You Seal a Pie Crust?

Go around the pie and pinch the two crusts together with your finger tips. You’ll want to be sure to cut vent holes in the upper crust so that the steam can escape while cooking.

How Do You Vent a Pie?

Once the upper crust is on the pie, use a table knife or a sharp kitchen knife and cut some slits in the pie at evenly spaced places around the pie to allow the steam to escape from the pie.

What Happens If You Don’t Vent a Pie?

If you don’t vent a pie the upper crust will separate quite a bit from the filling usually. Sometimes, the inside will leak out through the edges and then it will drip into your oven making a mess! ewwwww.

Should I Egg Wash My Pie?

This is entirely up to you, but it does make for a nice browned top crust that is very appealing. You’ll be proud of how it looks with an egg wash! Alternatively, you can paint the top crust with heavy cream!

Should I Boil or Fry The Chicken For This Pie?

You can do either one, but you’ll want to make sure that the chicken is very tender and easy to pull apart. Either way, you don’t want to overcook the chicken.

Can I Freeze Chicken Pie?

Yes, you sure can! Simply allow the pie to cool all the way, wrap it well in a freezer safe package and freeze for up to 3 months! Do just like you would a chicken pot pie recipe.

How Long Is Chicken Pie Good For?

This chicken pie will last 5 days if kept in the refrigerator. Do Not allow it to sit out for more than 2 hours.

What To Serve With Chicken Pie?

The best thing to serve with chicken pie is something simple!

We love Asparagus

Roasted Sweet Potatoes

Corn

followed by brownies! Yum!

TIPS AND TRICKS FOR Easy Chicken Pie

• This is a terrific dish to take for office parties and holiday gatherings! It fits easily inside a gallon zip lock bag if made in an aluminum foil pan.
• If you are going to make this as a “take it and toss it” dish – which I recommend for hostess or office party situations – then use the “deep dish aluminum pie pan” -it does give you a little wiggle room.
• I recommend tossing any leftovers before leaving the office party – because, I mean, honestly – don’t carry home a dirty disposable pie dish that everyone has had their hands on during cold and flu season. The nurse in me just can’t allow you to do that.
• Make sure to include reheating instructions for your hostess if you are leaving this with her as a hostess gift. “Allow to thaw and then reheat at 350 for 30-45 minutes until heated through – cover with aluminum foil if the crust appears to be browning too quickly”.
• This pie could just as easily be a Turkey Pie if that is what you have left over after Thanksgiving – just saying..
• I like to make several of these at once, keep them in the freezer and then, I am ready to go for either of the aforementioned situations OR on a night when I haven’t planned a single thing for supper. Easy Chicken Pie is terrific with a salad or some roasted veggies
• This recipe comes from the hand written collection of recipe cards that I found at a recent estate sale. I covered that sale HERE and included photos of an impressive collection of canned goods. I am still thinking about that canned food shelf.
• This recipe has been updated with my own instructions and adjustment of the ingredient amounts.

The Chicken

• If you are using a rotisserie chicken as your cooked chicken, then just use boxed chicken broth and stir in flour.
• Most people enjoy chicken breast for this recipe, but I personally recommend thighs.
• No need to use melted butter in the recipe, this melts all by itself.

If you Enjoyed This Recipe for Chicken Pie, You Might Also Enjoy…

How to Freeze Chicken

Easy Chicken Pie

How to Season Chicken

Basil Pesto Chicken

Pinto Beans

Do Me A BIG Favor?

Share this recipe or ANY you find on this site with a friend and leave a 5 STAR comment in the comment section below! These things help others to find Loaves and Dishes on the Internet!

Thanks Friend!

***This post originally appeared on the pages of Loaves and Dishes on November 29, 2016 and has been updated with “why this recipe works” “step by step” how it’s done, frequently asked questions, updated recipe card with nutrition information, equipment, video and notes” and the tips and tricks section has been updated. ***

In thinking about the patience that it takes to deal with Pete – I thought about how it probably requires a lot of patience of my family to deal with me. Sometimes I feel that way about them. The glue that holds us all together though is love. Without love, it all means nothing. That reminded me of this verse in 1 Corinthians. I hope this speaks to you today too.

1 Corinthians 13:

If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal…

And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love.